Parallel Anthology Track 25

From Open Music Archive Projects
Jump to: navigation, search
Icon Unknown Status.jpg Track 25: The Bentley Boys - Down on Penny's Farm   Columbia 15565; Recorded in Johnson City, Tennessee, 23.10.1929


Anthology Track 25 label.jpg
Record label does not assign authorship, nor does either Anthology booklet or www.78discography.com.


The Roud Folksong Index classifies this song as a version of Roud 6687, although a Roud number search does not return any versions which pre-date the Bentley Boys' recording.


Harry Smith's anthology notes call this song "a regionalized recasting of an earlier song 'Hard Times'."


This discussion on www.mudcat.org (post from 3.31PM, 9th September 07) gives the lyrics for a version of "Hard Times" dating from at least 1861. However, although there is a lot of similarity between the structure and lyrics of the two songs, the setting of the song is entirely different.


As the details of who wrote this version of the song, and when it was written are unknown, the copyright status of this composition is unknown.


Parallel anthology main index page


Alternative Versions

Hard Times in the Mill by Pete Seeger    album released in 1957: Spotify
 
Liner notes for this album date this song to 1890, credit authorship to the mother of a mill
worker, state that the melody comes from another song and make no claim to arrangement.
On Tanner's Farm by Gid Tanner and Riley Puckett    recorded in 1934 (according to RFSI): Spotify
 
No image of record label available. allmusic credits authorship of this song to Gid Tanner, who died in 1960 (according to wikipedia). 
However, this song is so similar to the
Bentley Brothers' version, other than the name "Tanner" being used instead of "Penny", that the validity of this claim seems doubtful.